The Unbilled Hours: Pricing the Work of Chasing a Debt
Photo: Richard Croft , CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Ask a UK supplier how long a customer takes to pay and most will answer in days. Ask what it costs to secure that payment and the answer is usually a shrug. Yet every chase has a price, and it is paid in the most finite resource a small business has: the attention of the people who could otherwise be selling, delivering or running the operation.
This is an argument for treating credit control as a cost centre with a measurable output, rather than as an unpleasant duty absorbed silently by whoever is nearest the ledger.
The number nobody puts on the invoice
A single overdue invoice is rarely a single event. It is a reminder email, a telephone call, a voicemail, a second call to a different extension, an internal conversation about whether to hold the next order, a note on the account, and eventually a decision about escalation. Each of those takes minutes rather than hours, which is precisely why the total is never noticed.
There is also the management layer. Any debt that reaches the point of a credit hold, a payment plan or a legal threat occupies someone senior. That time is the most expensive in the business and the least likely to be recorded.
Building a cost per chase
The calculation is not complicated, but it must be done honestly. Start with a fully loaded hourly rate rather than a salary figure. For a credit controller or finance assistant, total employment cost typically runs well above gross pay once employer National Insurance, pension contributions, holiday cover and a share of overheads are included. A useful shortcut is to multiply gross salary by a factor of between 1.3 and 1.5, then divide by roughly 1,500 productive hours a year.
Next, count the touches. Take a representative sample of ten overdue invoices from the last quarter and reconstruct the activity on each: emails sent, calls made, notes written, internal meetings held. Divide total minutes by the number of invoices to get an average minutes-per-chase figure. Multiply by the loaded rate.
A worked illustration: eleven touches averaging seven minutes gives seventy-seven minutes, or 1.28 hours, per invoice. At a loaded rate of £30 per hour, that is roughly £38 of staff time to recover one debt — before any management involvement and before the cost of the software, the statements and the postage.
Now scale it. A supplier raising two hundred invoices a month, of which a third are paid late, is processing something in the order of eight hundred chases a year. At the figures above, that is a little over £30,000 of annual effort — a salary, in effect, spent on asking for money that was already owed.
Comparing the cost with the remedy
The statutory remedy exists and is straightforward. Under the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 a supplier may claim interest at eight percentage points above the Bank of England base rate, running from the day after the agreed due date. Alongside interest, the 1998 Act and its 2013 Regulations provide fixed compensation: £40 for debts up to £999.99, £70 for debts between £1,000 and £9,999.99, and £100 for debts of £10,000 or more.
Set that against the £38 figure and two conclusions follow. First, on a small debt the fixed compensation alone will often cover the cost of a single disciplined chase, provided it is actually claimed. Second, most suppliers never claim it, which means the cost of chasing is funded entirely from margin while the remedy sits unused in the statute book.
That is the practical case for making statutory interest and compensation routine rather than exceptional. It is not aggression; it is the recovery of a cost that the late payer has imposed. A supplier who invoices interest and compensation as a matter of course is, in effect, part-funding its own credit control function.
Three thresholds: escalate, negotiate, stop
A cost figure is only useful if it drives a decision. Three thresholds are worth setting explicitly.
Escalate where the expected recovery comfortably exceeds the cost of the next stage. If a debt of several thousand pounds requires one more letter before a claim, the arithmetic is obvious. Escalation here means moving to a formal letter before action, a statutory demand where appropriate, or Money Claims Online in England and Wales — with the equivalent simple procedure in Scotland and small claims process in Northern Ireland.
Negotiate where the debt is material but the customer's difficulty is genuine and documented. A staged payment plan that recovers eighty per cent at modest administrative cost usually beats a full recovery achieved after eighteen months of chasing and a damaged trading relationship.
Stop where the cost of pursuit has overtaken the realistic recovery. This is the hardest threshold to accept, and it should be a written policy rather than an improvisation. Set a floor below which debts are written off after a defined number of touches, and a rule that a debt is abandoned once accumulated chasing cost reaches a stated proportion of its value. Record the decision, so that the same customer cannot quietly repeat the pattern.
Funding the function
None of this argues for chasing harder. It argues for chasing better: fewer, more structured touches; template letters that carry the statutory claim automatically; a clear internal owner; and a monthly review of what the process costs against what it recovers.
Late payment is usually discussed as a problem of cash. It is equally a problem of labour, and the businesses that treat it that way tend to be the ones whose credit control pays for itself.