Prompt Payment Directory All articles
Late Payment Law

The Old Debt in a New Invoice: Auditing a Buyer's Right of Set-Off

Prompt Payment Directory
The Old Debt in a New Invoice: Auditing a Buyer's Right of Set-Off

Photo: accountant reviewing contract clause with highlighter at office desk, via www.accountancyage.com

A remittance advice that arrives short is a familiar sight at this point in the year, when buyers are tidying their ledgers before the calendar closes. Sometimes the shortfall is a genuine dispute. Sometimes it is a delivery shortfall. And sometimes it is the buyer reaching back into an older account and taking an unrelated balance out of the payment for work you completed last month.

That last category deserves its own discipline. It is the one most easily mistaken for administration rather than a decision, and the one most likely to be accepted by default, because the supplier is chasing the larger number and has no appetite to reopen a smaller one.

There is no free-standing right to withhold

English law does not give a buyer a general licence to net off whatever it likes. Absent agreement, a customer that owes £10,000 on invoice 4471 cannot lawfully pay £7,000 because it believes you owe it £3,000 on a separate matter. Its remedy is to sue, or to counterclaim. Where two claims arise out of the same contract and are so closely connected that it would be manifestly unjust to enforce payment without regard to the cross-claim, the doctrine of equitable set-off may assist the buyer — but that is a narrow, fact-specific exception, not a default setting.

What most buyers actually rely on is contractual set-off: wording in the order or framework agreement permitting a deduction from any sum due of 'any amount owed by the supplier, whether under this contract or otherwise, and howsoever arising'. That language is common and, where properly incorporated, effective. It converts a legal argument into an administrative act.

The consequence is uncomfortable. Where the clause exists and the buyer holds a genuine, quantified cross-claim, a deduction from an invoice that was never itself in dispute may be lawful. Where the clause is absent, narrow, or never incorporated, the deduction is simply non-payment — and the late-payment clock under the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 continues to run on the full balance.

Three deductions that look identical on the page

Separating them is the whole task.

The first is lawful contractual set-off. The contract permits it, the cross-claim is real and quantified, and the buyer has identified what it has done. Your remedy lies against the underlying debt, not the mechanism.

The second is unilateral deduction without a right. No clause at all; or a clause confined to sums arising under the same contract when the debt relates to a different purchase order; or a 'debt' that is in truth a trading difference the buyer has never previously raised. Here the buyer has not set off — it has failed to pay. The distinction between those two positions is the distinction between a cash-flow inconvenience and a recoverable claim.

The third, and least comfortable, is set-off as leverage. An old query is revived precisely as a new invoice falls due, with no supporting paperwork, in the expectation that the supplier would rather absorb the deduction than litigate a stale point. This is not a legal category but a negotiating tactic, and it should be treated as a dispute from the first email.

Reading the clause as a lawyer, not a buyer

Retrieve the terms that actually govern the order — not those circulated during onboarding, and not whichever version currently sits on the buyer's website. Check four things.

Scope. Does the wording reach sums arising under other contracts, or only under this one? A same-contract clause cannot touch an older balance from a different purchase order.

Certainty. Does it require the sum to be 'due', 'undisputed', 'liquidated' or 'agreed'? Each qualifier narrows the buyer's freedom considerably. A clause limited to sums 'due and undisputed' cannot be used to collect a contested overpayment allegation.

Notice. Does the clause require notification, a debit note or an itemised statement? Where it does, silence is a failure to operate the mechanism — a useful point to make early.

Survival. Does the clause outlive termination? A framework that has ended may not authorise deductions against final invoices, depending on how it is drafted.

One set-off cannot be contracted out of at all: in the buyer's insolvency, mutual dealings are netted under rule 14.25 of the Insolvency Rules 2016 whatever the contract says. That is a solvency question rather than a payment-terms question, and it belongs with your credit function, not your sales team.

A challenge that does not freeze the relationship

The instinct to escalate immediately is understandable and usually counterproductive. A measured sequence works better.

  1. Acknowledge receipt, dispute the deduction, in writing, within five working days. State plainly that the full sum fell due and that the deduction is not accepted. Silence is the enemy; a supplier who queries a deduction three months later occupies a far weaker position.
  2. Request a set-off statement. Ask for the invoice number, issue date, amount and contract clause relied upon in respect of the older debt, together with any debit note raised. A buyer that cannot produce these has made an administrative deduction, not a set-off.
  3. Reconcile the account openly. Send a statement showing full invoice value, the deduction and the balance you consider due, with a note of the statutory interest accruing on that balance.
  4. Separate the two disputes. Deal with the old debt on its own merits and its own timetable, and insist the current invoice is settled in full meanwhile. Accepting that the two are linked is how a stale query becomes a standing discount.
  5. Do not issue a credit note merely to make the ledger balance. A credit note is evidence that you accepted the reduction; if you later recover the sum, you will be arguing against your own document.
  6. Reserve your rights expressly. Continue to claim interest and fixed compensation under the 1998 Act, and say so. Keep the language courteous and the record complete.

If the buyer still refuses to pay the balance and the sum justifies the effort, the next step is a pre-action letter supported by the correspondence built in steps one to six.

Drafting for the next order

Set-off is one of the few terms where suppliers routinely hold leverage and rarely use it. Three edits are worth requesting at renewal: a no set-off clause requiring payment in full without deduction; a same-contract limitation coupled with written notice and a debit note within a defined period; and a cap expressed as a percentage of invoice value. A buyer that genuinely intends to use set-off responsibly will usually accept all three.

A buyer that refuses all three has told you something useful about how it manages its ledger — and that is worth more than the clause itself.

All Articles

Related Articles

When the Buyer Writes the Bill: Self-Billing Controls for UK Suppliers

When the Buyer Writes the Bill: Self-Billing Controls for UK Suppliers

The Disputed Pound: Ring-Fencing the Undisputed Balance When a Credit Note Arrives

The Disputed Pound: Ring-Fencing the Undisputed Balance When a Credit Note Arrives

Sent Is Not Settled: Auditing Buyer Payment Claims and Protecting the Late-Payment Clock

Sent Is Not Settled: Auditing Buyer Payment Claims and Protecting the Late-Payment Clock